Problems [Re: WG Review: Operation of the IESG/IAB NominatingandRecallCommittees (nomcom)]

[Brian E Carpenter <brian@hursley.ibm.com>]

1. Effective impossibility for approving bodies to reject candidates without causing process collapse

2. Lack of clarity about role of liaisons

3. Lack of liaison from one of the approving bodies (ISOC Board)

4. Lack of clarity about verification that due process has been followed, without breach of
   confidentiality

5. Risks of NomCom membership bias due to repeat volunteers and/or volunteer pool stuffing

6. Lack of guidance to NomCom on past practice, balance, and turnover vs continuity

7. Administrivia (archiving, overlapping memberships, etc.)