Re: Problems [Re: WG Review: Operation of the IESG/IAB NominatingandRecallCommittees (nomcom)]

[Keith Moore <moore@cs.utk.edu>]

this list looks like a good start to me.

Keith

> 1. Effective impossibility for approving bodies to reject candidates without causing process collapse
> 
> 2. Lack of clarity about role of liaisons
> 
> 3. Lack of liaison from one of the approving bodies (ISOC Board)
> 
> 4. Lack of clarity about verification that due process has been followed, without breach of
>    confidentiality
> 
> 5. Risks of NomCom membership bias due to repeat volunteers and/or volunteer pool stuffing
> 
> 6. Lack of guidance to NomCom on past practice, balance, and turnover vs continuity
> 
> 7. Administrivia (archiving, overlapping memberships, etc.)