Re: Notes from one member of the IAB on the current draft

[Brian E Carpenter <brian@hursley.ibm.com>]

Most of these suggestions seem fine, but...

Michael StJohns wrote:

...
>  >>Replace section 3, paragraph 7 sub paragraph 3 paragraph beginning "If 
> some or none..." with:
> 
> "The confirming body may ask for additional information about a nominee 
> from the Nomcom to assist them in their deliberations. However, both the 
> confirming body and Nomcom should refrain from discussions of the 
> availability, qualification or characteristics of other possible candidates 
> for the position."

I have no problem with this as *additional* text, but I would object
to removing the original "If some or none..." paragraph, which I
believe is very necessary in its present form.

   Brian