Should the NomCom rules define CB voting behavior

[Avri Doria <avri@acm.org>]

Michael StJohns wrote:

> At 05:05 PM 3/31/2003 -0500, Avri Doria wrote:
>
>> Re. The rules under which the CB decides to accept or not
>> accept a slate. I.e. should 2727bis require a majority.
>>
>> It is the recommendation of the DT that it is not in the NomCom's
>> purview to decide how the CB makes it decisions.  The recommendation
>> is that 2727bis remove the requirement that at least 1/2 the CB
>> approve a slate.  NomCom rules are for the NomCom, not the CBs, they
>> make their decisions by whatever process their charters or practice
>> dictate.
>
>
> Again, please don't leave this in the hands of the CB.  The process at
> which the CB reaches a majority can safely be left there, but, if this
> is not externally specified, its not a given that the CB will establish
> rules to deal with the edge cases.
>
> Please specify at least the minimum required to let the CBs come to a
> conclusion.
>

discussion?