RE: Proposals for closing open issues

["Putzolu, David" <david.putzolu@intel.com>]

> > Rationale:  While the information is important for the IETF 
> > participants to understand the choices, publishing it prior to the 
> > nomcom making a choice may result less than useful public discussion

> > of that criteria and thrashing (as in "page thrashing") of the
process.
> 
> Rationale: I believe that it would valuable for the community to 
> provide feedback on the qualifications required for leadership 
> positions _before_ the leaders are chosen to fill them.  I also 
> think that posting the qualifications might help the community
> to identify and represent qualified nominees.

I agree with the point above.  Also,  the feedback/"thrashing" 
given might contain useful input to the decision making process.

Cheers,
David